The Black Friday Sale I Should Have Called Off
Updated: 3 days ago
Let me tell you about the Black Friday sale I should have called off, and what it taught me about planning a holiday offer.
Last October, I came up with an offer that was fairly easy for me to build and deliver. It was the Workshop Accelerator, an addition to my normal Book Club or my book Workshops Unleashed (like a paid Quilt-Along with a pattern) a new bundle I wanted to introduce during an early Black Friday sale.
I followed advice that I would give you as well when considering running a sale:
What worked at first for Black Friday
If you’re thinking about running a Black Friday sale, ask yourself these three questions before you commit:
Will this genuinely help my audience? Especially right now at this time of year?
Is it simple and easy for me to deliver? Is it something I already have? or could quickly create?
Do I have the bandwidth to fulfill this offer? What's your availability in terms of time, finances, and energy?
For example: a 15% off sale on PDF patterns:
Will this genuinely help my audience? Yes! Patterns are a great way to inspire crafters to create any time of year, but especially helpful when they're in a time crunch, like a few weeks before Christmas. Quick projects might be best here.
Is it simple and easy for me to deliver? Yes! Most web hosts will allow a coupon code or you can do a price markdown on your whole PDF Stock. Then write a few emails and purhaps a few social posts and you're good to go.
Do I have the bandwidth to fulfill this offer? Yes! You will only have to monitor your inbox for customer service (unless you have someone to cover that!) - the automated delivery will do the heavy lifting.
One more example: Kits
Will this genuinely help my audience? Yes! Kits give crafters a huge time-saving advantage to start a project.
Is it simple and easy for me to deliver? No (unless they're already made) - you will need to factor in price and time when it comes to packaging and shipping. Shipping does tend to take longer in the late fall and winter.
Do I have the bandwidth to fulfill this offer? Factor in the time, price, and energy. If you are traveling for a week or more, if you don't have help to fulfill, can you still fulfill these orders?
Consider these questions before diving into a sale for any time of year, but especially for Black Friday.
In regard to last year's sales, I answered yes to all three of the questions above, and I was excited to share it! I knew it would be a good deal, easy for me to implement, and could get my audience ready for January and the new year!
Then things took a turn. A fever hit. This wasn’t the good kind that comes with a new idea. It was a 102-degree fever that lasted days, with a cough and brain fog. Starting on Halloween and running until the first week of December, someone in our house was sick, recovering, or taking care of someone who was recovering, and some days I was all three at once.
Instead of pausing, I pushed through. I didn’t move the date, shrink the offer, or ask for help, and I kept going one foggy decision at a time.
I was wrapping up a Quarterly Book Club Meeting right after announcing the sale, and one of the people I was coaching walked me through my own sales process after asking more about it. It was a mess. The free book club sign-up wall came first, and the price wasn’t anywhere on that first page. I had bolted the sale onto my book’s landing page because I thought it would be clearer, but it ended up with multiple paths, multiple clicks, and so much confusion. All I could do was laugh and kick myself for pushing through when I should have rested (I'm learning).
The real facepalm came later, while I was moving my landing page tools to a more secure platform. I already had a landing page and email launch assistant. I had built tools for this exact situation, but in the fog I didn’t think to use them.
A year later, I can laugh about it and see what it taught me. I haven't made that mistake this year and hope to keep that record up! So, before you make a similar mistake, here's what I learned:
Check your capacity before you commit
An offer can be easy to build and still be wrong for the season you’re actually going to have. I answered “yes, it’s simple for me” on a good day, and that answer stopped being true the moment I got sick. Before you commit, look at your real calendar and energy, and ask whether you can deliver the offer if you get sick, get busy, or run out of room. Then look at your numbers. On our podcast episode with Quilting on the Side, my co-host Andi made a point that stuck with me: a deep discount can feel like a deal and still leave you working for nothing. Ask whether the sale covers your costs and your time, not just whether it looks good in a graphic.
Build the path in the right order
Start with the offer itself. Make sure the product or workshop exists in your shop and that people can get access to it without you. Then set up delivery, so the email or download happens automatically, even if you’re at Thanksgiving dinner. Next, build the landing page, because it becomes the source for everything else. It should show the price, what the buyer gets, and how to get it. Only after that come the emails, social posts, and guest appearances that point people there.
I did this backward. I bolted the sale onto a page that already existed, and I never gave it one clear place to land.

Use what you already built
I wanted something new for the sale, which is a common temptation. A brand-new product tends to get lost in the holiday noise, when everyone else is louder than usual. The better move is to offer something your audience already knows about, like a bundle of favorites or a discount on a product that’s already set up. The Book Cub I had all along would have done more for that sale than anything new I could have invented in the fog.
Plan your emails before the flood starts
Inboxes fill up in late November, and even your most loyal readers miss sale emails. People rarely curate their inboxes the way we like to think. They forget to unsubscribe until the holiday flood hits. Warn people early that a sale is coming, ask them to watch for your name, and send a little more often as the date gets closer. Not everyone agrees with sending more, and you know your list better than I do, but nobody can buy what they never saw.
Decide your pause rule before you need it
This is the lesson I most needed and didn’t have. Before you launch, write down the conditions under which you’ll move the date, whether that’s getting sick, not having the emails finished a week out, or not being able to test the path. When you’ve decided ahead of time, pausing feels like following your plan instead of quitting, and pushing through a sale you can’t run properly costs you more than a delayed launch does. I also fall for the pressure to sell almost every year, and I end up unprepared more often than I’d like. If you feel that pull around Thanksgiving, plan for it before it arrives.
The sale didn’t fail because I got sick. It failed because I treated my own systems as optional and tried to be a hero in the season when I needed help most. If you’re planning an end-of-year offer, look at what you’ve already built before you start typing, because those tools exist for the days when you can’t be at your best.
If you're looking for more help for Black Friday or any digital marketing advice, check out the Hey Tori Podcast! Answering Your Digital Marketing Questions for Creative Entrepreneurs. Where I answer questions from the audience, coach guests, and invite guest experts in to speak about their marketing efforts.





Comments